KCDC Called Out On Waste

Lyndy McIntyre

Former Councillor says Kapiti must take back waste management

By Alan Tristram

Former KCDC Councillor Lyndy McIntyre says the KCDC has failed in its attempt to privatise waste management. And it must now take

KCDC — caught out on waste?

the service back in-house.

She says: “The key point is that none of the available options in the ‘market’ now encourage a reduction of waste.
“Households pay for a waste collection and kerbside recycling and then can put out a huge amount (fill their wheelie bins every week) or zero waste. That is the only way to get a kerbside recycling service.
” But waste management is a basic service and should be provided by Council.”

Ms McIntyre says that before moving to the privatised system households had an incentive to minimise waste because citizens only had to purchase bags when they needed them (which could be never).
However, households which did this, still got a kerbside recycling.

Submission on the Kapiti Coast District Council Long Term Plan 2018/38 (Part A)

In her planned oral submission to Council, Ms McIntyre explains why Council should provide a kerbside recycling programme with a Waste Minimisation Incentive

She says: “For those of us who have continued with the remnants of the KCDC provided kerbside recycling scheme the recent announcement by Envirowaste that they are withdrawing has been a bitter blow, but not unexpected.

“It demonstrates the abject failure of KCDC abandoning kerbside recycling to the private sector and the absolute imperative of KCDC restoring a council-provided kerbside recycling service, coupled with a waste collection service which has a waste minimisation incentive.

“Now this experiment has come to an end, we should return to a ratepayer-funded kerbside recycling service, coupled with a waste to landfill collection service with incentivises waste minimisation.”


After EnviroWaste recently announced at short notice that they were discontinuing their service, KCDC issued a Q&A sheet.

Ms McIntyre says the KCDC question and answer sheet does not tell the whole story. It says: ‘In 2012-13 after community consultation, the Council made the decision to exit from kerbside collection services – at the time there were three other contractors also providing the service across the district.

“The reason for this change was that the alternative providers could provide more cost-effective services, at a much lower rate than the council could match. The difference in price was because the council had to cover the costs of providing kerbside recycling to those ratepayers who use the recycling service weekly, but only use the rubbish bag infrequently,” she says.

“I was a KCDC councillor in the 2007-2010 triennium. The scheme to privatise our waste was implemented well before 2012, so any consultation in 2012/13 planning process was well after the horse had bolted.

In fact, KCDC effectively exited kerbside recycling and, perhaps more importantly, waste ministration, in the 2007-10 term after a privatisation proposal was sold to councillors by senior KCDC management.

( Note from the Editor: I remember this well during my term as Councillor, which ended in 2007. We were sold a pup! — Alan Tristram) 

Part A ends; Part B tomorrow


Absolutely to all that, Lyndy and Jackie. And Jackie, you need to make a heck of a fuss at Council to ensure that it happens – many many of us will support you. I believe that Janet Holborow was wavering on this after her initial position that Council could do nothing – so let’s all work hard on this.
Prue Hyman

Thanks Lyndy and Alan for the super background information. Especially the accurate dates. This is exactly while I say today that KCDC should provide a fit for purpose waste collection service. This contract has 5 years to run. (Yes it is a contract although even that is now being denied by council) I can not imagine just how out of kilter with our waste minimisation aspirations, any services we have left will be by 2024.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.