Poisoning Forests = Remedy for Drought? 1

Today we begin a three part article by well known expert on ecosystem modification in New Zealand, Bill Benfield. Bill is the author of “The Third Wave: Poisoning the Land” and regularly features in the “Tasmania Times”. This article was first published in that paper on 5 March 2016.

Forest modification over millions of years

By Bill Benfield

Forest modification goes back along way
Forest modification goes back along way

The forests of ancient Gondwana, New Zealand (shared with Tasmania), have been suffering die back and hillsides collapsing in great slips which have scarred the land for millions of years. If this is the case, what was the cause of these disasters before possum and deer came along?

Firstly, it is because much of the land is geologically young and unstable.Secondly, it is under the strong influence of a maritime climate and subject to cyclical extremes, of periods of storms which are often followed by periods of droughts.

We also know that pre-human forests were subject to intensive browse by birds, ranging from giant moa to bush pigeon, as well, by insects ranging from stick insects to the many grubs of moths and beetles. Browse shaped the forests. This changed with the coming of the Maori, which brought about the first mass extinction and a consequent major change to the forest ecology.

Observations on natural processes bringing change

A constantly changing pattern of growth and decline
An on-going process of growth and decline

New Zealand’s written records start at forests modified by Maori, but as yet unmodified by European arrivals. The journals of the first botanists and explorers such as William Colenso prove interesting, because he actually travelled through untracked forests, mainly in the Ruahine Ranges, in the 1840’s.

His journals chronicled a forest in a state of change, mainly from climatic factors. Before any effects from introduced browsers, he found massive slips and fallen forests from storms.

Drought which can be correlated actual records is also noted by the hydrologist Dr Patrick Grant as a cause of die back which can result in permanent forest changes, such as changing the height of the bush line. An interesting feature is the delayed impact of the real effects of drought. Though Waipawa records show severe drought in the years 1914 – 15, it was not till 1917, several years later that the full damage was obvious.

The impact of extreme weather

So too today, weather events that can affect forests are occurring, and can be verified by both observation and their impact. A case in point is Northland, where drought has been declared in both January and December 2010 and again in 2013.

A Forest and Bird drone photo purporting to show forest damage from pests
A drone photo purporting to show forest damage in Northland from pests (Credit: Forest and Bird)

It was no surprise then, that meteorologist Dr Jim Sallinger was reported in the New Zealand Herald of 3/4/13 that forest was at risk of die back over a wide area from Wairarapa to Northland. Without significant rain, he predicted century old native trees were at risk of dying due to drought. The accompanying photo showed dying trees.

A later paper quoting Salinger on Sciblogs of 14/10/14 chronicles events, ranging from global climate change, residual effects from ozone depletion and changing wind patterns from the Southern Annular Mode (SAM) as being current drivers of increasing drought.

Higher temperatures from the drought have a multiplier effect as plant evapo-transpiration increases with heat, it exacerbates the damage to both forests and farms.

( In the second part of the article, Bill examines the hysterical campaign by Forest and Bird and others, to solve the perceived Northland forest “problems” with poison.)

Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thank you
so much, However I am going through problems with your RSS.
I don’t understand why I can’t join it. Is there
anyone else getting the same RSS issues? Anyone that knows the
solution can you kindly respond? Thanx!!

I do not know if it’s just me or if everybody else experiencing problems with your blog.
It appears like some of the written text within your content are running off the
screen. Can someone else please comment and let me know if this
is happening to them as well? This may be a issue with my browser
because I’ve had this happen previously. Many thanks

We’ll look into this asap. And try to let you know. Thank you for joining us, Editor (Alan Tristram)

Very gently press and massage watching the receiver face to
make sure what you are doing is pleasurable for him.
Transgender: Can be either a person born with both male and female genitals or fall under the umbrella of being a
transsexual. It also helps fight toxicity released from nitrogen and the metabolic function of the

Bill Benfield has done a service to factual reporting addressing the current frenzy by Forest & Bird et al to demonize the possum follows hot on the heels of the last avenue for blaming the possum for being the main vector for Bovine Tuberculosis on farms.This tactic has been soundly disproved by none other than information via the Departments of Conservation response Official Information Act (OIA) To quote extracts–Tb Free autopsied 124,213 possums over nine years and found only 54(0.4%) were found to be carriers i.e.99.96% of possums were disease free,even the 54 could have been infected by cattle?Last year 9838 possums were tested and found to be clear.Once more this is another attempt to raise $60 million to keep the gravy train going.The system is bankrupt and nothing short of a major overhaul of wild life management under professional control will root out this malaise.

Bill Benfield is so right. In about 1960, I came across William Colenso’s graphic descriptions of the natural erosion and forest damage in Ruahine Ranges in Colenso’s biography by Bagnall. I related it in a Wellington NZDA newsletter where probably botantist/hydrologist Dr Patrick Grant saw it and set about looking at the Ruahines. His work is in his excellent book “Forests of Yesteryear. The dead giant spars of century or more old trees were said by Forest and Bird, Forest Service, Catchment Board etc., to be due to possums and deer. Dr Grant identified climate cycles and successive droughts 1909-15 as stressing and causing trees to die. Bill Benfield’s two very good books should be read by all, especially by Forest and Bird disciples and Department of Conservation employees, Green Party MPS and Environment minister Nick Smith and Conservation minister Maggie Barrie. I’m sure they would all be enlightened.
Tony Orman