Are Horowhenua Ratepayers Paying Twice?

Lake Horowhenua (photo by David White)

Horowhenua correspondent Veronica Harrod says Horizons Regional Council wants ratepayers to pay again for a plan to cut sediment flowing into Lake Horowhenua.

It wants ratepayers the plan to reduce sediment loss entering Lake Horowhenua — even though the project was one of several that received $1.27 million funding in 2014 – including $540,000 from the Environment Ministry’s Freshwater Fund.

Largely on roadsides and private land

A report presented to Horizons strategy and policy committee on 13 November asks for funding to “scope and price” the development of an integrated sediment and drainage management plan for the Arawhata Catchment that flows into Lake Horowhenua .

The report claims  “the work is outside of the area that is administered by the Lake Trust on behalf of the Beneficial Owners of the lake. This project is largely based on roadsides and private land.”

Ministry’s statement

But the Environment Ministry’s website states the total funding package for the Lake Horowhenua Project was to complete a range of projects including, “An integrated stormwater management plan for the Arawhata sub-catchment to reduce sediment loss from horticultural farms and the stormwater drainage network.”

Lake Horowhenua — already one of the ‘most polluted’ lakes in NZ

A February 2017 update on completed projects does not mention the integrated stormwater management plan.

Horizon’s report

The Horizons report says, “Once the scope and costings have been further developed, staff will bring an item to council to consider if the work should proceed and how it would be funded.”

The report states that monthly monitoring clearly shows that the Arawhata Stream is the largest contributor of sediment and phosphorus load to the lake.

“A more recent study has confirmed the Arawhata is currently the major contributor of sediment to the lake. The study was completed as part of the Te Mana o Te Wai project for Lake Horowhenua led by the Lake Trust was completed in collaboartion with Massey University and National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research Ltd (NIWA).”

For the last five years the Arawhata Stream catchment has been identified as the source of between 48 and 75 percent of sediment, and the Mangaroa Stream catchment has been contributing between 20 per cent and 45 per cent.

“In addition, the sediment accumulation rates have increased in recent times.”

The report says the Arawhata Catchment has a mix of land use that, “ includes lifestyle blocks, dairy farming and approximately 400 hectares of horticultural land use” but a 2015 Horizons report said the catchment, “services some 620 hectares of cropping and dairy farms to the south of Lake Horowhenua….that ultimately discharges into Lake Horowhenua.”

The boundaries of the Arawhata catchment include Arawhata Road, State Highway 1, Hokio Beach Road and Buller Road.

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.